25. Mike Mamula – 7th overall to Eagles in 1995:
Mamula may be the most cautionary tale of combine success not translating onto the field in draft history. He compiled 26 reps of 225 pounds on the bench, more than Tony Boselli, the top offensive lineman taken that year. A 4.58 40 time had scouts’ jaws agape. Mamula also scored a 49 out of 50 in the Wonderlic Test, which is the second-highest score ever for an NFL athlete. Mamula also recorded a 38.5″ vertical jump, and a standing broad jump of 10’5″. He played five years for the Eagles and had decent enough numbers, racking up 31.5 sacks during that time.
But the fact the Eagles traded the No. 12 pick for him, a pick that eventually was used to select Hall of Famer Warren Sapp, makes him a surefire bust to a large degree. The Eagles also gave up two second-round picks in addition to the Sapp pick, adding insult to this injury.
