23. Corey Coleman -15th overall to Browns in 2016:
The jury is technically still out on Coleman, as he could surface on an NFL field this season. However, his career as the 15th pick in 2016 has been an unmitigated disaster up until this point. He showed flashes of potential during his rookie year but was ultimately limited by a broken hand.
The same hand limited him the following year, requiring surgery. He came back at the end of the 2017 season but ultimately dropped a pass in the final game to cement the Browns’ dismal 0-16 season that year. Coleman bounced around from the Buffalo Bills to the New England Patriots to finally the New York Giants. Perhaps the biggest factor in his bust status was that the Browns traded the No. 2 pick in 2016 to select him, where they could have selected promising quarterback Carson Wentz.
